Audit Supervisor - NFP

A growing CPA firm in Bergen County, NJ, is seeking an Audit Supervisor with at least 7 years of public accounting experience specializing in nonprofit organizations. They're looking for a seasoned CPA who can step into complex client situations, take full ownership, and elevate both the team and the practice. This is a true leadership-minded role with meaningful impact.

About the Role What You'll Work On Lead audit engagements, manage and mentor staff, review work, prepare deliverables, and guide clients through strategic planning. You'll be hands-on with a diverse mix of nonprofit organizations that demand real technical depth, including:

• Risk assessment
• Preparation of financial statements and disclosures
• Uniform Guidance audits
• Preparation of Form 990 returns for tax-exempt organizations

This role does not involve:

• Public company or SEC work
• Big-firm siloed specialization If that's your background or primary interest, this may not be the right fit.

Key Responsibilities

• Supervise staff during fieldwork, review workpapers, and provide constructive guidance and suggestions
• Develop testing methodologies to evaluate the adequacy of internal controls
• Review audit findings, recommend changes in accounting practices, and improve client efficiencies through corrective action plans
• Recommend corrective actions and offer operational improvements
• Supervise, mentor, and develop staff and seniors; manage workloads and deadlines effectively
• Build and maintain strong client relationships through ongoing communication and best-in-class service
• Stay current with changes in laws, accounting guidance, and related compliance matters
• Contribute to internal process improvements and best-practice refinement

Required Qualifications

• Active CPA license required
• Minimum 7 years of progressive public accounting experience
• Deep knowledge of nonprofit accounting
• Strong background in Uniform Guidance audits
• Strong background in preparing Form 990 returns for exempt organizations
• Demonstrated leadership with a track record of developing staff and managing client engagements
• Ability to handle multiple priorities without losing accuracy or momentum
• Solid working knowledge of ProSystem Engagement, PPC Smart Tools, ProSystem fx, QuickBooks, and QuickBooks Online is a plus

What They Offer

• A stable client base of nonprofit organizations
• A firm culture that values accountability, professionalism, and exceptional client service
• Competitive compensation, benefits, and opportunities for long-term growth
• A clear partner-track path for the right candidate